Read Audi ELV MC68H908GR16 with Xprog or VVDI Prog

ELV AUDI MC68H908GR16 mcu read by Xprog or VVDI Prog, which is faster?

1)Read 908GR16 with Xprog
Require xprog version newer than 5.70 (Xprog v5.70, 5.745.84)
Connect ELV 908GR16 mcu with Xprog via HC(S)12 BDM adapter
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-1

xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-2
In Xprog-m software, select Freescale MCU MC68H908GR16_FLASH+ security
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-3
select Read Security Bytes
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-4
Bypass security
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-5

Xprog m read security byte success, press OK to continue
Go to Options tab->Environment->Device->Manual
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-6

xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-7
Manully enter security bytes
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-8
Read 908GR16 in process
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-9
Verify device
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-10
Read data success
xprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-11
Save data.
Reading procedure takes 1 minute and 59 seconds
2) Read 908GR16 with Xhorse VVDI Prog
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-1

vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-2
Follow wiring diagram to connect VVDI prog with ESL
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-3

In VVDIProg software, select Audi ESL HC08GR16 V1
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-4
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-5

Read data
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-6

Verify data
vvdiprog-read-audi-elv-908gr16-7

Save data
Reading process takes 2 minutes.
In conclusion:
Xprog is cheaper and faster than VVDIProg in Audi ELV 908GR16 reading.
http://blog.obdii365.com/2019/03/12/read-audi-elv-esl-hc908gr16-with-xprog-or-vvdi-prog/